When It Comes To Pizza, Special Offers Trump Taste Every Time

LOS ANGELES , October 24, 2012 () – I live approximately one mile from both a Pizza Hut and a Papa John’s. And all things being equal, I like Papa John’s better. I find it to be very tasty. Good sauce, decent amount of cheese, not too oily, and a crust that’s soft but not too soft.

The prices are comparable for both pizza chains. Neither charge for delivery, and if I have the urge to get carryout, the drive is the same.

But every time I order pizza, I go to Pizza Hut. Why?

Simple: Meal deals.

Pizza Hut routinely trumps Papa John’s in special offers. The company consistently sends coupons to my house. It regularly features a $10 any-size, any-toppings offer and often that offer extends to delivery (which is highly convenient for large parties).

And as a result, every time I think about pizza, I think about Pizza Hut, even if it doesn’t have a promotion at the time. It has established brand loyalty with me even though there’s a Papa John’s right near me that I actually like better.

Recent numbers and surveys highlight this point. According to a survey by Market Force, Papa John’s is America’s second-favorite pizza chain, behind only CiCi’s Pizza. However, while Papa John’s reported net earnings of $14.8 million in its latest financial report, Yum! Brands—Pizza Hut’s parent company, which also owns Taco Bell and KFC—reported earnings of $331 million.

Quite a difference, no?

* All content is copyrighted by Industry Intelligence, or the original respective author or source. You may not recirculate, redistrubte or publish the analysis and presentation included in the service without Industry Intelligence's prior written consent. Please review our terms of use.