Companies in Spain having to pay three times more to borrow than German peers--4.2% versus 1.5%--threatening to stifle economic recovery needed to provide jobs for the 25% of people in country looking for work

July 9, 2014 () – Companies in Spain are having to pay three times more to borrow than their German peers, potentially stifling an economic recovery needed to provide jobs for the one in four people in the country looking for work. Adjusted for expected inflation, Spanish banks charged 4.2 percent for loans of more than one year in May, just below a euro-era record of 4.39 percent in April, according to Bank of America Merrill Lynch estimates based on European Central Bank data. German lenders demanded 1.51 percent.

High real borrowing costs risk hampering the investment needed to boost an economy recovering from a six-year slump, tackle the budget deficit and create jobs. The stock of loans to non-financial companies and households in Spain is declining at twice the pace of 2011, when Draghi took over at the ECB.

“Lenders in the periphery still see a significant credit risk,” said Stefano Loreti, a partner at Hayfin Capital Management LLP, which manages about 5 billion euros ($6.8 billion) of assets, including Spanish loans. “It’s a bit too early to say that we’ve left the credit crisis behind.”

Ten-year Spanish government bonds, a benchmark for corporate borrowing costs, yield 2.7 percent after stripping out inflation, according to Bloomberg data. Equivalent German bunds pay 0.22 percent. The 2.5 percentage point gap compares with an average of 1.6 points since the global financial crisis erupted in 2007.

Competitiveness Loss

More than a year after the euro area exited its longest recession and with interest rates close to zero, the Frankfurt- based ECB is still battling below-target inflation and trying to revive demand.

ECB President Mario Draghi introduced an unprecedented range of measures last month including a negative deposit rate and long-term loans for banks willing to boost credit to companies and households. He also said buying assets with newly created money remains an option if deflation appears.

The prospect of quantitative easing, first signaled in April, has helped reduce the gap between Spanish and German real borrowing costs, though the narrowing has been partially reversed.

“As long as real rates in Spain remain high on a relative basis, companies based in the country have to gain competitiveness via other tools such as labor costs,” said Cesar Fernandez, a Madrid-based fund manager at Deutsche Asset & Wealth Management, which oversees about 934 billion euros of assets.

Rajoy’s Challenge

Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy is counting on the recovery to tackle a government debt burden approaching 100 percent of gross domestic product and bring down the highest jobless rate in the European Union after Greece. Spain’s economy, the euro area’s fourth largest, is still almost 7 percent smaller than at its peak in 2008.

To see an investment revival, “it is key that real interest rates remain low across countries,” said Ruben Segura- Cayuela, a London-based economist at Bank of America Merrill Lynch.

Spanish companies put off by the cost of borrowing are instead seeking short-term money, though little of it is being used for investment, said Carlos Ruiz, head of financing at business lobby CEOE.

“Companies are raising debt for working capital rather than for longer-term investment plans,” Ruiz said in a July 7 telephone interview. “The extra borrowing cost makes it harder to keep the competitiveness gained via the reduction of prices and costs.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Esteban Duarte in Madrid at To contact the editors responsible for this story: Heather Harris at Andrew Atkinson, Rodney Jefferson

* All content is copyrighted by Industry Intelligence, or the original respective author or source. You may not recirculate, redistrubte or publish the analysis and presentation included in the service without Industry Intelligence's prior written consent. Please review our terms of use.